We encourage you to post your questions about kitchen knives here. We can give you help choosing a knife.
Thu Jun 27, 2013 11:06 pm
1. Left handed (maybe convert to right hand if necessary)
2. Yanagi, Nakiri
3. standard sizes? Yanagi ~270mm sounds right, Nakiri ~ any size?
4. Stainless steel (easy maintenance)
5. Japanese handle
6. $300 for both
7. Yes, I can sharpen
Buying a gift for a friend who wants to be an amateur Sushi chef, I think a Yanagi and Nakiri would be a good start for him. I currently have a Shun Classic Santoku with paka wood and VG-10 that he seems to like, but I want to get him something different, a bit more traditional.
If I can get both knives that come from the same line (looks similar in style), that would be perfect. Any suggestions would be appreciated! Love this site. Thanks in advance!
Thu Jun 27, 2013 11:22 pm
I have to say that price point for LEFTY stainless Wa's is a difficult one. CKTG just picked up a new line of knives that fit your request for righty chisel grinds, but I have no first hand experience nor have I heard any reviews as they are that new. http://www.chefknivestogo.com/kijo.html
. You would have enough money left in budget to add some sayas if CKTG says their universals fit.
AUS-8 steel I have been very pleased with in many of my folding knives, but I've never experienced it in kitchen cutlery.
Fri Jun 28, 2013 12:30 am
Does your friend need a nakiri, or would they be better served by either a better yanagiba alone, or a different knife in the pair? I can't say that I've found much of a use for a nakiri myself, nor do I see them often on the line at a sushi bar in the US. Even for the daikon/cucumber peeling cut, a yanigiba can be used.
As you say that your friend is looking at sushi for fun (as opposed to apprenticing for a career), perhaps a sujihiki might be a more versatile option than a yanigiba? It's also ambidextrous...
Fri Jun 28, 2013 7:25 am
Welcome to the site.
A couple of words of advice first:
Any lefty, stainless yanagi for under $300 by itself would be suspect IMHO. I can't imagine that it would be very nice.
Budget yanagi can be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for a newbie to maintain. They often times come with serious flaws. Knowing how to recognize them and the ability to fix the issues is part of owning budget yanagi. Now, a $300 right handed, carbon steel yanagi isn't what I would consider in this category.....but a $300 and under, lefty, stainless yanagi would be.
My recommendation would be to either get him/her a 270mm stainless sujihiki (double beveled slicer and still works well for sushi) and a stainless nakiri.
Get a lefty, carbon 270mm sujihiki for $300. This will still be hard to find a quality example. Lefty's get screwed with traditional Japanese knives.
Fri Jun 28, 2013 10:21 am
Thanks for the advice, guys.
- I will take another look at the AUS8A Kiyotsuna Josaku, it looks the part, I'm just concerned about edge retention. I'll do some research on that steel
- He likes to do some mean chopping with vegetables, so a nakiri may suit him.. but I will consider dropping this for a better quality slicer.
- You guys may be right about the sujihiki. I was hoping to stay away from carbon (because he's lazy). I'll watch his technique to figure out how he handles the blade. That may give me a better impression of his slicin and dicin skills.
I will continue to look for some stainless steel knives in this order:
2) Right handed yanagi (he's a lefty, but may cut with his right, I need to check)
Thanks a lot!!
Fri Jun 28, 2013 11:24 am
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.
phpBB Mobile / SEO by Artodia.