Switch to full style
We have a massive amount of Edge Pro products so we figured it would be good to have a whole section on how to use the machine and what to use on it.
Post a reply

Why do my stones crack and break?

Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:47 pm

I take care of my stones (chosera set). I let them air dry and then wrap them in some cloth towels. I do not bang my edge pro case on anything, yet the stones crack. The 3k stone cracked after the first use, and I saw that my 5k has cracked when I went to use it today, and while sharpening a piece of the stone just fell off.
Why is that happening?

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Mon Jan 20, 2014 8:58 pm

They seem to become week after cutting them for the EP. There has been a lot of complaints about the choceras for the EP cracking.

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sun Jan 26, 2014 8:24 pm

I've had two of my Ep Shapton glass stones break as well, the 500 grit at the corner and the 8000 grit. I have been being very very careful how i pack them away using the bubble wrap

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sun Jan 26, 2014 8:33 pm

I had the same problem with Choseras for the EP. But I switched to Shapton glass and have NO problems. And i'm not even particularly careful with them. Also no problems with Nubatamas and I soak them pretty long before use. Sometimes I wonder if soaking or over soaking would cause problems. I would guess that would be the case if the Shapton glass stones were soaked, but someone more knowledgeable would have to address that.

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sun Jan 26, 2014 10:34 pm

I think the aluminum plates shrink and swell a lot until the stone cracks.

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Mon Jan 27, 2014 2:11 am

Magnesia stones are a bit more prone to cracking. So for instance the Nubatama 4k and 6k Ume stones are also magnesia based and [theoretically] more prone to cracking. For this reason, I usually recommend the 4k and 6k Bamboo stones. Having said that, I have yet to get a single instance of this cracking actually reported for these two stones. The attractiveness of Magnesia based stones is in their smooth feel and feedback so it is an individual trade.

I don't think the aluminum plates shrinking and expanding is the cause or even a cause or else you would see the problem occurring in all stones with equal frequency.

One could postulate other theories - that stones that absorb water crack more easily than more splash and go stones or that the thinner Choceras crack more easily than thicker Choceras, but the data is too inconsistent to draw conclusions here.

Of course direct sunlight exposure and rapid temp changes exacerbate the likelihood of cracking, but it doesn't sound like this is what is being discussed here as care has been taken to eliminate those variables.

It remains a bit of a mystery since most don't have this problem with these stones, so it's just idiosyncratic.


Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sun Feb 16, 2014 4:59 pm

It is the stones getting wet and drying. Then gluing them, this won't let the stone expand and contract. I wonder if a guy just left them in water all the time it wouldn't be better? Cutting the stones thick would help or not putting anything on the back and just let the E.P grab the stone. This would be the same way it holds on to the DMT plate I doubt very much aluminum shrinks or expands at the temperatures we are talking about. Since it's coefficient of linear expansion is fairly low. Not as low as glass, but that's why a lot of gun stock manufactures use aluminum bedding blocks.

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sat Feb 22, 2014 3:16 pm

Ive had my Choseras for a little over a year. No cracking or issues. I always let them soak for 10 minutes before I use them, squirt water on them after every 3-4 passes on the EP. I also flatten them before each use. Thats my routine, and its worked well.

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sun Mar 16, 2014 11:43 am

Temperature is one reason. Use room temp water.

Pressure is one reason. Use light pressure.

Storage is one reason. Store them in a stable environment.

Try switching to Shapton Glass stones for the edge pro. We almost never have issues with cracking with them. They're twice as thick which helps and they use ceramic abrasive that doesn't seem to crack.

I've tried dozens of different stones and these are the best on this machine. Splash and go, slow wearing and they cut a wide variety of steels nicely.

Re: Why do my stones crack and break?

Sun Mar 16, 2014 5:21 pm

already did mark, I wish I knew this beforehand, I would have gone for the shapton set, and not the chosera :(
Post a reply