We encourage you to post your questions about kitchen knives here. We can give you help choosing a knife.
Thu Apr 04, 2013 11:45 am
mark, looking at a 180mm Deba, prefer Blue#2, but open to advise.Love the Doi
but $475 has me looking at other options. Tanaka Kasumi is Blue#2 at $175. what
are specs on Tanka? Is the Doi that much better or is it just because of the
known name (Doi)? also Kaneshige looks similar but ws#2 - think Blue is better
when cutting thur/around bones. Awaiting Specs on tanaka and any advise/opinion
You might share.
Thu Apr 04, 2013 11:46 am
Save the money and get the Kaneshige. White #3 is a great steel for a deba. It's
not as chippy as blue #2 so if you hit an occasional bone there is less chance
of it chipping. Also the blade is forged by one of the best blacksmiths working
in Japan today (i promised not to tell his name) but you get a great knife for
the money with that one. Debas tend to get used less than gyutos so owning a
good but less pricey one is a good idea in my opinion.
Thu Apr 04, 2013 4:55 pm
Adam Marr, Mark Richmond said I should get your advise on buying a 180mm Deba. 3 choices If money was no object I'd get Kejiro Doi Blue#2 ($477), but since $$$ do matter there are 2 other options Tanka Blue#2 which looks similar (handle sucks) or Kaneshige White#3 (Know what sk, white#1, & white#2 are but no ideal what WS#3 is) also (handle sucks). I have put several handle on myself so no big deal there. Both these are same price ($175). I was thinking Blue steel less brittle for bone contact, but Mark said WS#3 less brittle than Blue steel. Your thoughts would be appreciated! Also have a western handle & a Japanese handle On knives You did for Mark - Real nice craftsmanship.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 1:50 am
I'd agree with Mark in suggesting the white steel as preferred for a knife that does chopping. The Nubatama blacksmith also uses and prefers to use white steel for his debas in preference to blue or even black steel. The white is less 'chippy'. Of course this does depend on the skill of the bladesmith using the steel to forge and temper it appropriately for the knife's use.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 7:41 am
Although the heat treat will matter some in this discussion, as a general rule, white steel is typically less chippy than blue.
Of the one's you listed, I'd take the Kaneshige because of this.
BTW, thanks for the compliment.
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.
phpBB Mobile / SEO by Artodia.